NESCAC Championship Appearances: 17 (2001, 2003-05, 2007, 2008, 2011-18, 2021-23)
Overall Record: 28-23
NESCAC Titles: 5 (2004, 2005, 2013, 2018, 2021)
2023
Game 1: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 4W Amherst, 12-6
Game 2: No. 4W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 8-3
Game 3: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 4W Amherst, 12-5
2022
Game 1: No. 4W Amherst def. No. 1E Bowdoin, 17-6
Game 2: No. 4W Amherst def. No. 1E Bowdoin, 9-2
Game 3: No. 1W Middlebury def. No. 4W Amherst, 14-8
Game 4: No. 2W Hamilton def. No. 4W Amherst, 15-8
2021 (NESCAC Champions)
Game 1: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 6-2
Game 2: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 4-1
2018 (NESCAC Champions)
Game 1: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 2E Bates, 3-12 (12 inn.)
Game 2: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 9-2
Game 3: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 3-2
2017
Game 1: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 5-4
Game 2: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 2E Bates, 5-3
Game 3: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 2-1
2016
Game 1: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 5-4
Game 2: No. 2E Trinity def. No. 2W Amherst, 13-6
2015
Game 1: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 5-2
Game 2: No. 1W Wesleyan def. No. 2W Amherst, 4-2
Game 3: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 2E Bates, 6-5
Game 4: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1W Wesleyan, 3-1
Game 5: No. 1W Wesleyan def. No. 2W Amherst, 4-3 (12 innings)
2014
Game 1: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 9-5
Game 2: No. 2E Wesleyan def. No. 2W Amherst, 4-2
2013 (NESCAC Champions)
Game 1: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1E Trinity, 8-5
Game 2: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1W Wesleyan, 5-4 (13 innings)
Game 3: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1W Wesleyan, 7-0
2012
Game 1: No. 2E Bowdoin def. No. 1W Amherst, 3-2 (11 innings)
Game 2: No. 2W Williams def. No. 1W Amherst, 9-3
2011
Game 1: No. 2E Bowdoin def. No. 1W Amherst, 9-8
Game 2: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 2W Middlebury, 7-3
Game 3: No. 2E Bowdoin def. No. 1W Amherst, 6-5 (10 innings)
2008
Game 1: No. 1E Trinity def. No. 2W Amherst, 9-1
Game 2: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1W Williams, 9-8 (10 Innings)
Game 3: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 2E Tufts, 10-7
Game 4: No. 1E Trinity def. No. 2W Amherst, 11-8
2007
Game 1: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1E Tufts, 8-7
Game 2: No. 1W Williams def. No. 2W Amherst, 6-3
Game 3: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 9-4
2005 (NESCAC Champions)
Game 1: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 2E Tufts, 5-3
Game 2: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Trinity, 6-0
Game 3: No. 1E Trinity def. No. 1W Amherst, 11-5
Game 4: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Trinity, 8-7 (10 innings)
2004 (NESCAC Champions)
Game 1: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1E Trinity, 16-8
Game 2: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 2E Bowdoin, 4-1
Game 3: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 1W Williams, 5-4
2003
Game 1: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 2E Tufts, 5-1
Game 2: No. 1W Amherst def. No. 1E Trinity, 3-2
Game 3: No. 1E Trinity def. No. 1W Amherst, 11-6
Game 4: No. 1E Trinity def. No. 1W Amherst, 5-3
2001
Game 1: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 6-3
Game 2: No. 2W Amherst def. No. 2E Trinity, 4-1
Game 3: No. 1E Tufts def. No. 2W Amherst, 7-3
