by Justin Long
Andrew Reed '12 was born one minute before his twin brother, Will '12. If that doesn't sound like much of a difference, you don't know Andrew and Will.
Some of their first memories are of playing one-on-one football in the front yard (they called the game "Offense/Defense"). Their mom played the role of quarterback as Will pretended to be Deion Sanders and Andrew elected for Troy Aikman, Michael Irvin or any other member of the Dallas Cowboys, the brothers' favorite childhood team.
Rain or shine, Andrew and Will would ask their mom to drop what she was doing in order to play. But being the quarterback was no easy task. If she threw better passes to one of them than to the other—giving even the slightest hint that she was playing favorites—she would quickly hear about it. She got yelled at a lot, but when Andrew and Will reflect on those days they are quick to point out that she was the best quarterback ever. (She didn't have much of a choice.)
So began a lifelong competition between Andrew and Will. Most of their recurring arguments have simply been carried over from childhood. For example, they fight over which brother is the better basketball player. (The answer is still very much up for debate.) Getting one Reed to admit that the other is better at something is about as easy as getting a Patriots fan to wear a Jets hat. They even argue about who wins their arguments.
Their competitive nature is the reason Andrew and Will are both two-sport athletes at Amherst. Will made Amherst's football and lacrosse teams as a freshman, but Andrew was lined up to play only football (his self-proclaimed "mediocre baseball career" fizzled out in high school). Dreading the thought of letting his younger brother show him up as a two-sport star, Andrew joined the track and field team. Last year he earned All-America honors at the NCAA Championships as a member of the 4x400 relay, a remarkable accomplishment considering he didn't run track in high school.
That "Anything you can do, I can do better" mentality is the foundation of their relationship. "A lot of it is just pushing each other to be the best we can be," Will says. "We want to see each other succeed. I'm his biggest fan, and he's mine—but I usually win the arguments."
Andrew and Will no longer play Offense/Defense (although Will still wears No. 21 in honor of his childhood admiration of Deion Sanders), but those countless games in the front yard and thousands of throws from Mom have turned them into an outstanding duo at Amherst. They have each caught 41 passes heading into Saturday's game and have combined for 11 touchdowns and more than 1,100 receiving yards.
Both Reeds have been great players, but they've gone about it in different ways. Andrew is a full-speed-ahead type of receiver who takes the cap off the coverage and has averaged 19 yards per catch in his career. In 2009 his 70-yard touchdown reception at Williams ignited a 23-0 run. He might be the fastest player in the NESCAC. (Will jokes that the only thing Andrew can do better is run straight.)
Will is more of an inside receiver who relies on quickness rather than flat-out speed. He has caught two touchdowns in each of the past two seasons and tends to play his best against the likes of Trinity and Williams. "He's great at catching across the middle in tight spaces," Andrew says. "He rises to the occasion when the light is on the prize. It motivates me to step up my game."
Their different receiving styles match their personalities. Will works better under pressure and is more likely to finish a paper the night before it's due. Andrew prefers to get ahead and stay on track, both in class and in football. "Andrew is the most prepared player on the field," Will says. "It's like that in the classroom, too. Being a double major isn't the easiest way to get through Amherst, but he's so dedicated to being the best he can be."
Andrew and Will have the same friends and have lived together for the past three years. They spend the majority of their time together, but they have their own identities. "What amazed us was that Andrew and Will were so similar looking, yet they were able to define themselves as two individuals," says Doug Burdett, their guidance counselor at Brunswick School in Greenwich, Conn. "It's hard to find that with identical twins."
Andrew and Will were model students at Brunswick, and now they're standing out at Amherst. Will maintains a 3.44 GPA as a history major. Andrew majors in classics and economics with a 3.81 GPA. (And remember, they're two-sport athletes.) Will is known for his ability to take over a room and make everyone laugh. Andrew is incredibly reliable and trustworthy (former Amherst president Tony Marx asked him to babysit). You can't go wrong with either one, and that's probably the biggest thing they have in common.
Upon graduation, Andrew will work in San Francisco at Goldman Sachs, handling investment banking for the company's Technology, Media and Telecommunications group. Two weeks before Andrew lined up that job, Will was offered a position with Bank of America Merrill Lynch in New York. ("He was insufferable for those two weeks," Andrew says.)
Andrew and Will didn't plan on attending the same school, but they're glad it worked out that way. Whether it's sharing a celebratory moment on the sidelines after a win over Williams or exchanging a look before making a big play against Trinity, they have felt fortunate to experience this together. "It's been an amazing three years," Andrew says. "Completing anything means so much more because I'm sharing it with Will. Looking back, I can't imagine not going to school with him."
Andrew was born one minute before Will. Next May he'll graduate less than a minute before him. My guess is they'll exchange one last look before receiving their diplomas. You might see Andrew smile back at his younger brother, knowing that he was the first to officially graduate. He'll beat him by just a few seconds, but it's enough to chalk up as a win. After all, it's always a competition with those two.
##