Postseason History

NESCAC Championship Appearances: 23 (2000-19, 2021-2023)
Overall Record: 29-13-5
NESCAC Champions: 7 (2001, 2003, 2011, 2016, 2019, 2022, 2023)

NCAA Championship Appearances: 21 (1994-98, 2001, 2003, 2006, 2008, 2009, 2011-16, 2018, 2019, 2021-23)
Overall Record: 37-16-5
National Finalists: 1 (2001)
National Semifinalists: 1 (1996)
National Quarterfinalists: 5 (1995, 1997, 2006, 2008, 2011)

2023 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 8 Tufts, 3-1
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 4 Wesleyan, 1-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 3 Bowdoin, 2-1

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Maine Maritime, 5-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. RIT, 3-1
NCAA Third Round: Messiah def. Amherst, 3-1

2022 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 8 Conn. College, 3-0
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 7 Tufts, 1-0 (OT)
NESCAC Finals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 6 Wesleyan, 2-0

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Westminster College (PA), 3-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. RIT, 1-0
NCAA Third Round: William Smith def. Amherst, 2-1

2021
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 8. Trinity, 2-1 (OT)
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Amherst ties No. 4 Middlebury, 2-2 (Middlebury advances on PK's, 4-3)

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Lesley, 6-1
NCAA Second Round: Johns Hopkins def. Amherst, 2-1

2019 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 4 Amherst def. No. 5 Hamilton, 1-0 
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 4 Amherst def. No. 1 Tufts, 3-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 4 Amherst def. No. 2 Middlebury, 1-0

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Maine Maritime, 5-0
NCAA Second Round: Dickinson def. Amherst, 1-0

2018
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 3 Amherst def. No. 6 Hamilton, 1-0
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 3 Amherst ties No. 2 Middlebury, 1-1 (Middlebury advances on PK's, 4-3)

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Lesley, 3-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. MIT, 1-0
NCAA Third Round: William Smith def. Amherst, 2-1

2017
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 7 Amherst def. No. 2 Conn. College, 1-0
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Williams def. No. 7 Amherst, 4-2

2016 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 7 Conn. College, 6-1
NESCAC Semifinals:  No. 2 Amherst def No. 3 Middlebury, 2-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 2 Amherst def No. 4 Trinity, 2-1

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Lasell, 4-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Swarthmore, 4-2
NCAA Third Round: William Smith def. Amherst, 4-2

2015
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 6 Middlebury def. No. 3 Amherst, 3-2

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Colby-Sawyer, 1-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst ties Brandeis, 1-1 (Brandeis advances on PK's, 3-2)  

2014
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 5 Middlebury def. No. 4 Amherst, 1-0

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. NYU, 2-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst ties Nazareth, 2-2 (Nazareth advances on PK's, 4-3)

2013
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 4 Trinity def. No. 5 Amherst, 2-1

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Springfield, 1-0
NCAA Second Round: Messiah def. Amherst, 2-0

2012
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 3 Amherst def. No. 6 Colby, 1-0
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 4 Bowdoin def. No. 3 Amherst, 3-1

NCAA First Round: Lasell def. Amherst, 3-1

2011 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 8 Bowdoin, 3-2 (OT)
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 5 Wesleyan, 3-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 3 Williams, 2-1

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Castleton St., 3-1
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Misericordia, 3-1
NCAA Third Round: Amherst def. Johns Hopkins, 2-0
NCAA Quarterfinals: Messiah def. Amherst, 3-1

2010
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 7 Bowdoin, 3-2
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 8 Bates, 4-1
NESCAC Finals: No. 3 Williams def. No. 2 Amherst, 1-0

2009
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 7 Wesleyan, 2-1 (OT)
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 3 Middlebury def. No. 2 Amherst, 1-0

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. ECSU, 3-0
NCAA Second Round: TCNJ def. Amherst, 4-0

2008
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 7 Wesleyan, 1-0
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 3 Middlebury, 1-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 1 Williams def. No. 2 Amherst, 3-2 (OT)

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Farmingdale State, 4-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Springfield, 3-0
NCAA Third Round: Amherst def. Otterbein, 1-0
NCAA Quarterfinals: William Smith def. Amherst, 1-0

2007
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 6 Middlebury def. No. 3 Amherst, 1-0

2006
NESCAC Quarterfinals: Bye
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 1 Amherst def. No. 7 Bates, 3-0
NESCAC Finals: No. 3 Middlebury def. No. 1 Amherst, 1-0 (OT)

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Kean, 2-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Wheaton (MA), 3-0
NCAA Third Round: Amherst def. Endicott, 1-0
NCAA Quarterfinals: Amherst ties TCNJ, 0-0 (2 OT) (TCNJ advances on PK's)

2005
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst ties No. 7 Colby, 0-0 (Colby advances on PK's, 4-3)

2004
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 7 Conn. def. No. 2 Amherst, 1-0

2003 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 2 Amherst ties No. 7 Tufts, 0-0 (Amherst advances on PK's, 4-2)
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 2 Amherst ties No. 3 Williams, 1-1 (Amherst advances on PK's, 3-1)
NESCAC Finals: No. 2 Amherst def. No. 4 Bates, 6-0

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Bridgewater State, 1-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Endicott, 2-1 (OT)
NCAA Third Round: Wheaton (MA) def. Amherst, 3-2

2002
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 5 Conn. def. No. 4 Amherst, 2-1

2001 (NESCAC Champions)
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 3 Amherst def. No. 6 Tufts, 3-1
NESCAC Semifinals: No. 3 Amherst def. No. 2 Middlebury, 5-1
NESCAC Finals: No. 3 Amherst def. No. 1 Williams, 2-1 (2OT)

NCAA First Round: Amherst def. Endicott, 6-0
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Wheaton (MA), 4-1
NCAA Third Round: Amherst def. WCSU, 2-1 (2 OT)
NCAA Quarterfinals: Amherst def. William Smith, 1-0
NCAA Semifinals: Amherst def. Wheaton (IL), 1-0
NCAA Championship: Ohio Wesleyan def. Amherst, 1-0

2000
NESCAC Quarterfinals: No. 6 Williams def. No. 4 Amherst, 1-0

1998
NCAA First Round: Bye
NCAA Second Round: Amherst ties Williams, 0-0 (2 OT) (Williams advances on PK's)

1997
NCAA First Round: Bye
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. WCSU, 2-0
NCAA Third Round: Amherst def. William Paterson, 3-2 (3 OT)
NCAA Quarterfinals: Elizabethtown def. Amherst, 1-0

1996
NCAA First Round: Bye
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Richard Stockton, 2-1 (2 OT)
NCAA Quarterfinals: Amherst def. Bates, 1-0
NCAA Semifinals: UC San Diego def. Amherst, 2-1

1995
NCAA First Round: Bye
NCAA Second Round: Amherst def. Bowdoin, 1-0
NCAA Quarterfinals: Amherst ties Richard Stockton, 1-1 (4 OT) (RSC advances on PK's)

1994
NCAA First Round: Amherst def. UMass Dartmouth, 4-2 (2 OT)
NCAA Second Round: TCNJ def. Amherst, 1-0